Step 1 of 8
Welcome!
Let's learn how to use the search features effectively.
Step 1 of 7
Welcome!
Let's learn how to use the search features effectively.
Latest Judgments (All Jurisdictions within Pakistan)
Robkar-e-Adalat VS Liaqat Ali Mir
Summary: Background:
The Supreme Court of Azad Jammu and Kashmir initiated contempt of court proceedings against Liaqat Ali Mir, the Deputy Registrar (Judicial) of the High Court of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, for entertaining a writ petition filed by Mujahid Hussain Naqvi that contained scandalous, contemptuous, and objectionable content. The writ petition disparaged the judiciary, including the Chief Justice and Senior Judge of the Supreme Court of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, and used highly indecent and immoral language.
----Issues:
1- Whether the writ petition filed by Mujahid Hussain Naqvi containing contemptuous contents can be entertained by the Courts.
2- Whether the language and contents of the writ petition violate constitutional provisions, particularly concerning public order, decency, and morality.
3- Whether contempt of court proceedings are warranted against the Deputy Registrar for accepting such a petition.
----Holding/Reasoning/Outcome:
The Supreme Court found that:
The language and contents of the writ petition were highly scandalous, contemptuous, and against the morality, decency, and public order mandated by the Constitution of Azad Jammu and Kashmir.
The Deputy Registrar, Liaqat Ali Mir, acted irresponsibly by entertaining the petition and should have rejected it outright due to its contemptuous nature.
The respondent apologized unconditionally and placed himself at the mercy of the Court, admitting his error in judgment.
The Court accepted the apology of Liaqat Ali Mir and discharged the contempt notice against him. However, the Court emphasized the importance of maintaining the dignity and independence of the judiciary and instructed all concerned to avoid entertaining petitions that violate constitutional limits and decorum.
----Citations/Precedents:
The Prisoners Act, 1894
Muhammad Ikram Chaudhary vs. Federation of Pakistan [PLD 1998 SC 103]
Dr. D.C. Saxena Contemnor v. Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India [AIR 1996 SC 2481]
In Re: Professional Conduct of Two Lawyers in Civil Miscellaneous Petition No.45 of 1982 [1982 SCMR 713]
Various relevant case laws from Pakistan and Azad Jammu and Kashmir pertaining to contempt of court and judicial decorum.
Messrs POPULAR SUGAR MILLS LIMITED vs DISTRICT COLLECTOR SARGODHA and 2 others
Summary: Summary pending
Dr MUHAMMAD ARIF vs MUHAMMAD ANWAR and 3 others
Summary: Summary pending
Malik MUHAMMAD RAMZAN vs ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN MARKET COMMITTEE RAJANPUR and others
Summary: Summary pending
NASEER KHAN vs The STATE
Summary: Summary pending
GUL HASSAN vs The STATE
Summary: Summary pending
Liaqat Ali VS The State
Summary: Post arrest bail application through jail due to corona pandemic
RASHID IQBAL vs CHANCELLOR BAHAUDIN ZAKARIA UNIVERSITY MULTAN and 4 others
Summary: Summary pending
MUHAMMAD SUMAK MALIK and antherss vs MUHAMMAD ASIF KHAN and 3 others
Summary: Summary pending
Syed SAKHAWAT MOHSIN vs The STATE
Summary: Summary pending